Elden Ring Review: A Masterpiece of Open-World Design

June 10, 2024 By Michael Chen Game Reviews 15 min read

FromSoftware has done it again. With Elden Ring, director Hidetaka Miyazaki and his team have not only crafted what might be their most ambitious title to date but have also redefined what an open-world game can be. Collaborating with George R.R. Martin, the creator of A Song of Ice and Fire, FromSoftware has built a hauntingly beautiful world filled with danger, mystery, and the studio's signature challenging gameplay.

A Vast and Intricate World

The Lands Between, Elden Ring's sprawling open world, is a masterclass in environmental design. Unlike many modern open-world games that feel padded with repetitive content, every inch of this realm feels purposeful and handcrafted. From the golden-leaved forests of Limgrave to the rot-infested swamps of Caelid, each region has its own distinct visual identity and atmosphere.

What makes Elden Ring's world truly special is how it encourages genuine exploration. There are no quest markers cluttering your HUD or telling you where to go. Instead, points of interest are organically revealed through visual cues in the environment. You might spot a distant castle on the horizon, the glow of a strange tree, or a winding path leading into a mist-shrouded valley. These sights naturally draw you forward, creating a sense of discovery that feels earned rather than prescribed.

Combat Excellence

Elden Ring builds upon FromSoftware's combat foundation with new mechanics that add unprecedented depth and variety. The game offers more build diversity than any previous Souls title, with an extensive array of weapons, spells, and abilities to discover and master. Whether you prefer to wield colossal greatswords, rain down arcane spells, or summon spirit allies to fight alongside you, there's a playstyle to suit your preferences.

The addition of mounted combat on your spectral steed, Torrent, opens up new tactical possibilities, especially when facing the game's largest foes. Meanwhile, the stealth system allows for more methodical approaches to enemy encounters, giving players more agency in how they tackle challenges.

Of course, the difficulty that FromSoftware is known for remains intact. Boss fights are grand, multi-phase affairs that will test your reflexes and pattern recognition. However, the open-world structure means that if you hit a roadblock, you can simply explore elsewhere, level up, and return stronger – a welcome change from the more linear progression of previous Souls games.

Rich Lore and Storytelling

Like previous FromSoftware titles, Elden Ring's narrative is largely environmental, told through item descriptions, cryptic NPC dialogue, and the visual language of the world itself. The collaboration with George R.R. Martin has resulted in a deep mythological foundation for the game's setting, with a complex history of gods, demigods, and ancient conflicts for players to uncover.

While the main story follows your Tarnished character's quest to repair the shattered Elden Ring and become Elden Lord, numerous side quests branch off in unexpected directions. These optional storylines are often as compelling as the main narrative, featuring memorable characters with their own motivations and secrets.

Technical Performance

On current-gen consoles and PC, Elden Ring generally maintains a solid framerate during gameplay, though there are occasional dips in particularly effect-heavy areas. The art direction more than makes up for any technical limitations, with stunning vistas and imaginative enemy designs that showcase FromSoftware's unparalleled artistic vision.

The sound design deserves special praise, from the haunting orchestral score that accompanies boss fights to the subtle environmental audio cues that help bring the world to life. Voice acting is excellent across the board, with performances that convey the gravity and tragedy that permeates the Lands Between.

Conclusion

Elden Ring represents the pinnacle of FromSoftware's design philosophy – challenging but fair, mysterious yet rewarding, and built upon a foundation of exploration and discovery. It successfully translates the tight, focused level design of the Souls series into an open-world context without sacrificing what made those games special.

This is a landmark title that will influence open-world game design for years to come. For longtime Souls fans, it's everything you could hope for and more. For newcomers, the more accessible structure might finally provide an entry point into FromSoftware's unique brand of action RPGs. Either way, Elden Ring stands as one of the finest games of this generation – a true masterpiece of its genre.

Elden Ring FromSoftware Game Review RPG Open World